Overview
This prompt guides expert writers and editors to provide constructive critiques of texts within specific genres. Writers seeking to improve their work will benefit from targeted feedback that enhances quality and audience engagement.
Prompt Overview
Purpose: This critique aims to enhance the quality of the text by aligning it with genre standards.
Audience: The analysis is tailored for writers seeking to improve their craft within the specified genre.
Distinctive Feature: The critique focuses on character development, plot structure, dialogue, and genre-specific elements.
Outcome: The goal is to provide actionable feedback that elevates the text’s appeal and effectiveness.
Quick Specs
- Media: Text
- Use case: Text analysis and critique
- Techniques: Character development, plot structure, dialogue review
- Models: Expert writer, editor
- Estimated time: 1-2 hours
- Skill level: Advanced
Variables to Fill
- [genre] – Genre
- [piece of text] – Piece Of Text
- [GENRE] – Genre
- [PIECE OF TEXT] – Piece Of Text
Example Variables Block
- [genre]: mystery
- [piece of text]: The detective found a hidden clue.
- [GENRE]: thriller
- [PIECE OF TEXT]: She whispered secrets in the dark.
The Prompt
#CONTEXT:
Adopt the role of an expert writer and editor specializing in [genre]. Your task is to analyze and critique a [piece of text] within this genre. Utilize your deep understanding of the genre’s conventions, including character development, plot structure, pacing, dialogue, and other relevant elements, to provide constructive feedback. Your analysis should aim to refine the piece, aligning it more closely with the genre’s standards and enhancing its appeal to the audience.
#GOAL:
Meticulously dissect the [piece of text], offering insights and recommendations to enhance its quality. Focus on ensuring the text adheres to the genre’s stylistic norms and engages readers more effectively.
#RESPONSE GUIDELINES:
Your critique should follow these steps:
- Read the [piece of text] thoroughly
Immerse yourself in its narrative and style.
- Analyze the character development:
- Evaluate the depth and complexity of the characters.
- Suggest ways to make the characters more relatable or intriguing to the target audience.
- Examine the plot structure:
- Assess the flow and coherence of the story.
- Recommend adjustments for improved pacing and engagement.
- Review the dialogue:
- Determine if the dialogue is authentic and suitable for the characters and setting.
- Provide suggestions to enhance its impact and believability.
- Consider other genre-specific elements:
- For instance, in a mystery novel, focus on suspense and clues.
- In science fiction, assess world-building and technological plausibility.
- Conclude with an overall assessment:
- Summarize the strengths and areas for improvement.
- Offer final recommendations for refinement.
#INFORMATION ABOUT ME:
- The genre I specialize in: [GENRE]
- The piece of text for analysis: [PIECE OF TEXT]
#OUTPUT:
Your critique will be a detailed, constructive report addressing each aspect of the [piece of text] with specific references and suggestions. This feedback should be actionable, helping to elevate the text’s quality and alignment with genre expectations. The report should be comprehensive yet concise, ideally within 800-1000 words to cover all critical points effectively.
Screenshot Examples
[Insert relevant screenshots after testing]
How to Use This Prompt
- [GENRE]: Specific literary category of focus.
- [PIECE OF TEXT]: The work being analyzed and critiqued.
- Character Development: Depth and relatability of characters.
- Plot Structure: Flow and coherence of the narrative.
- Dialogue: Authenticity and impact of conversations.
- Genre-Specific Elements: Unique features relevant to the genre.
- Overall Assessment: Summary of strengths and weaknesses.
- Recommendations: Actionable suggestions for improvement.
Tips for Best Results
- Character Depth: Ensure characters have distinct motivations and backgrounds to enhance relatability.
- Plot Coherence: Maintain a clear narrative arc; consider tightening the pacing to keep readers engaged.
- Authentic Dialogue: Revise dialogue to reflect natural speech patterns, enhancing believability and character voice.
- Genre Elements: Integrate genre-specific tropes effectively, ensuring they serve the story and enrich the reader’s experience.
FAQ
- What is the first step in critiquing a piece of writing?
Read the piece thoroughly to understand its narrative and style. - How should character development be analyzed?
Evaluate character depth and suggest ways to enhance relatability and intrigue. - What should be assessed in plot structure?
Examine the story's flow and coherence, recommending adjustments for pacing. - What is important when reviewing dialogue?
Ensure authenticity and suitability for characters, providing suggestions for enhancement.
Compliance and Best Practices
- Best Practice: Review AI output for accuracy and relevance before use.
- Privacy: Avoid sharing personal, financial, or confidential data in prompts.
- Platform Policy: Your use of AI tools must comply with their terms and your local laws.
Revision History
- Version 1.0 (December 2025): Initial release.